For All Mankind Season 5 is turning out to be quite as unimpressive as its predecessor.
Season 4 was dull because it stripped the show of what makes it unique: the massive humanity feats that had been the cornerstone of the narrative.
This season leans hard into the Mars and Earth politics, making the entire show feel different from where we started.
Critic’s Rating: 2.5 / 5.0
For All Mankind Season 5 is turning out to be quite as unimpressive as its predecessor.
Season 4 was dull because it stripped the show of what makes it unique: the massive humanity feats that had been the cornerstone of the narrative.
This season leans hard into the Mars and Earth politics, making the entire show feel different from where we started.

It’s even worse now because there are too many characters, and we’re being told what they represent rather than shown.
That’s why For All Mankind Season 5 Episode 6, “No Sudden Moves,” lacks an identity and feels like the least For All Mankind episode yet.
It plays out like a thriller but without differentiating itself as a heist, hostage, or political thriller. There is even some romance sprinkled in here.
The show has been straining to contain all the characters it has added over the seasons while dealing with the natural consequences of keeping things in the family.

Families tend to expand the father you get away from the oldest living member of the tree.
What started as Ed and Karen Baldwin’s family now includes Kelly and Alex. The addition of another generation changes everything, as they bring different ideas and procedures.
But even more importantly, the number of characters increases. The show is officially too small to tackle a narrative of this magnitude spanning multiple settings.
“No Sudden Move” deals with the fallout from the Mars riot as the Marsies take control of the base and demand that automation be stopped.
It would be a very interesting storyline to explore in another timeline in which For All Mankind was about interplanetary colonization.
But alas, that’s not what this show is about; it’s about going out there into the unknown, conquering fears and physics to propel our species into places we’ve never been before.

And that is still present, but Soujourner’s is treated as a supporting character instead of the main character.
Even when we check on Kelly and the crew, it’s about the chaos at Happy Valley, not their mission.
Half the season is already gone, and we’ve made little to no progress with the storyline that we’re all here for: life on other planets.
Instead, we’re saddled with the good old storyline of humans fighting over whose dick is bigger.
If I sound frustrated, it’s because I am.
I’ve tried to remain neutral for the past several episodes because I thought things would pick up. At this point, I don’t feel as hopeful.

In 45 minutes, we touch on every character, even some like Miles who had become the show’s wallpaper this season.
As chaos reigns in Happy Valley, it doesn’t feel as chaotic as the show would have it.
It feels like a setup for whatever the writers want to say in the coming episodes about the future of Mars and Earth.
Dev’s city idea has been playing out in the background, and this development seems like an attempt to propel it without any groundwork.
It hasn’t even been the most interesting storyline in the show since Edi Gathegi has been playing the same emotion throughout the season.
And you can’t even blame him when this is what he’s working with.

The battered face at the end of the episode is the most acting he’s had to do this season.
That’s why we check in on Danny’s daughter, who is now friends with Alex’s friend from the season premiere.
These new characters add to an already bloated season, and most are not even worth remembering their names.
What was supposed to feel like war instead feels like a political negotiation, with each side unwilling to come to the table.
Earth spins the Mars riot as terror and justifies treating them like subhumans.
“America does not negotiate with terrorists” is a line that felt empowering in the aftermath of 9/11, but doesn’t stand up to scrutiny in the real world.

It becomes unimpeachable when you label people with genuine grievances as terrorists and go after them.
If they weren’t terrorists, then they would surely become them soon.
But again, this show is not the platform for such ideas.
And by the end of the episode, what felt like a bomb waiting to go off turns out to be a helium balloon.
While it felt premature to call this season a lost cause, I feel more emboldened now.
I never thought there’d come a day when For All Mankind would fail to excite me when I started watching it all those years ago.

“No Sudden Move” should have featured a sudden move. That would have at least made it interesting.
It’s like watching a thriller without the thrills. Marsies kept undercutting themselves at every turn.
Earth does not need to do much to break these people.

Over to you, For All Mankind fanatics. What do you think of the story this hour? Am I overreacting, or is the story all over the place now?
Let’s keep the conversation going — it’s the only way the good stuff survives.
Say something in the comments, share if you’re moved to, and keep reading. Independent voices need readers like you.
Auto Amazon Links: No products found.