What happens when the planets align in a dinner setting? Well, you might get a hidden camera scheme worthy of a Hollywood script! Just when you thought the “Call Her Daddy” saga couldn’t get any juicier, former co-host Sofia Franklyn is ready to spill the tea in her memoir “Daddy Issues.” She claims that her ex-BFF, Alex Cooper, enlisted her to covertly photograph a dinner with on-again, off-again beau Noah Syndergaard. But hold onto your horoscopes, because these snaps weren’t just for reminiscing! Franklyn alleges the pics were intended as leverage against Syndergaard’s mother, a twist that would make even the nosiest Sagittarius raise an eyebrow. And what’s a celebrity drama without a hint of scandal? Rumor has it that the images somehow ended up online, leaving Franklyn pointing fingers in the aftermath. Buckle up, because this tale is about to take you on a cosmic rollercoaster!
Sofia Franklyn is bringing an alleged photo scheme out of the darkroom. In her new memoir, “Daddy Issues,” the former “Call Her Daddy” co-host claims Alex Cooper asked her to secretly photograph a dinner with then-on-again, off-again boyfriend Noah Syndergaard. But according to Franklyn, the pictures weren’t meant for a scrapbook. She alleges Cooper wanted them as leverage involving the former New York Mets pitcher’s mother. The story takes another turn when the image allegedly ended up online, leaving Franklyn pointing toward her former friend.

According to Page Six, Franklyn’s memoir revisits Cooper’s relationship with Syndergaard during his time with the Mets. The pair were reportedly on a break when the athlete invited Cooper to dinner. Franklyn writes that Cooper thought the invitation might lead to them getting back together. While preparing for the evening, Cooper allegedly asked Franklyn, her New York City roommate at the time, to photograph them at the restaurant.
At first, Franklyn thought she was being invited to join the dinner. She says she soon realized the assignment was something closer to “paparazzi-type sh-t.”

Franklyn claims Cooper had a specific explanation for wanting photographic evidence of the evening. “He’s just such a sh-t, and I want to have them in case I need to send them to his mom,” Cooper allegedly told her, according to the memoir excerpt reported by Page Six.
Franklyn says she agreed and successfully snapped the pair together.

The dinner wasn’t the end of the story. Franklyn writes that the image later appeared on a “Z-list sports coverage site that covers women linked to semi-famous athletes.” Page Six connected her description to a January 2018 Busted Coverage article that credited an anonymous tipster with submitting a photo of Cooper and Syndergaard.
Franklyn denies sending the picture to the website. She also claims that only she and Cooper had access to it.
The allegation also reaches back to before Cooper and Franklyn became a famous podcasting duo. “Call Her Daddy” launched later in 2018, making the dinner story a glimpse into the friendship before their business partnership took off.

Released Tuesday, November 10, “Daddy Issues” also revisits the much more public breakup that followed. Cooper and Franklyn built “Call Her Daddy” together before contract negotiations with Barstool Sports turned into a highly publicized dispute in 2020. Franklyn ultimately left, while Cooper continued hosting the show alone. Cooper’s subsequent agreement allowed her to retain the podcast’s intellectual property, setting up its later move beyond Barstool.
The memoir now gives Franklyn another opportunity to tell her side, including stories about their personal relationship alongside the business fallout.

Franklyn wasn’t ready to put her side of the “Call Her Daddy” breakup on bookshelves right away. In a March YouTube video, she explained that she needed some distance before telling the story honestly and “ego-removed.”
“I needed to grow up,” she said.
Cooper has already shared her perspective. In her 2025 Hulu docuseries, “Call Her Alex,” she said she wanted to accept the deal offered during their contract dispute, while Franklyn did not. Cooper stayed with the podcast, and their partnership ended.
Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy has also said Franklyn declined the offer. Now, with “Daddy Issues,” she’s giving readers her account of how it all fell apart.

Before the memoir reached readers, it was reported that people acting on Cooper’s behalf were trying to find out what Franklyn had written. The outlet described tightly controlled advance copies, with recipients’ names watermarked on the pages. “She’s in full-on panic mode,” one source who reportedly received an advance copy and was approached about its contents claimed.
With “Daddy Issues” now available, the dinner-photo allegation is another chapter in the former co-hosts’ fractured friendship. Whether Cooper or Snydergaard will publicly address Franklyn’s account remains to be seen.
Auto Amazon Links: No products found.