A musical about George Floyd, of all things, has created quite the uproar! It’s like the universe decided to align the planets just right for a storm of controversy—one that raises a ton of unsettling questions about the ethics of transforming real-life tragedies into a two-act show. Following the casting call by Playbill for Busted Broadway’s “George Floyd The Musical,” the internet exploded into a flurry of gasps and outraged tweets. You know, it’s one thing to push boundaries in art and another to handle such heavy topics with a proverbial feather. Speculation about the line between satire and respect has everyone buzzing, while Playbill hurriedly backpedaled, apologizing for their “incorrectly approved” casting notice. With the planets in disarray and emotions running high, this scenario poses a question for the ages: How far is too far when it comes to art and tragedy? If Mercury’s in retrograde can’t save us from this, what can? To dive deeper into this brewing storm, read on… LEARN MORE
A musical about George Floyd has sparked widespread backlash, raising questions about the boundaries of satire and the ethics of turning real-life tragedies into entertainment. The controversy erupted after Playbill apologized for publishing a casting notice seeking vocal talent for Busted Broadway’s “George Floyd The Musical,” which features satirical recordings centered on the 46-year-old man murdered by police officer Derek Chauvin in 2020. Floyd’s death sparked widespread protests against racial injustice and police brutality.
On November 18, Playbill Jobs posted a casting call for Busted Broadway, seeking singers for the upcoming project “George Floyd The Musical” and its album recording.
The post drew intense backlash, prompting Playbill to pull the advertisement from its website and make a public apology.
In an Instagram post, they said the job listing was “incorrectly approved,” and it was immediately taken down. Playbill further noted that they were “reviewing and revising” their job listing approval process and promised to “do better going forward.”
“For that, we are sorry, and are committed to regaining your trust,” the statement concluded.
While many accepted the apology, others questioned how the casting notice was “incorrectly approved” in the first place and whether the person responsible had been dismissed.
The independent musical theater record label teased the album on its website with a cartoon image of George Floyd on the ground with three police officers and a $20 bill with the text “COUNTERFEIT.” The text below read, “The $20 bill that changed the world.”
It was a reference to the $20 fake bill that Floyd used to purchase cigarettes in 2020, which prompted the cashier to call authorities. Trial testimony noted that Floyd was most likely unaware that he used counterfeit money.
Busted Broadway responded to the backlash, clarifying that they were “not making light of, condoning, or mocking the horrific 2020 murder of George Floyd.” Instead, they claim the recordings will be a satirical take on the “culture” following the murder.
“Never judge a show by its title, as many who have never seen the script or score appear to be doing now,” they wrote.

Activist and actress Malynda Hale posted screenshots of the Playbill ad in an Instagram Reel, writing, “This is so outrageously disrespectful I truly have to ask HAS EVERYONE LOST THEIR DAMN MINDS?!”
Oscar-winning actress Viola Davis reacted to Hale’s post, writing, “I mean….. WHAAT??!!! I would’ve lived to have been in the room when this one was pitched!” followed by an exploding head emoji.
Drummer and record producer Questlove also weighed in, saying it took a few moments for the words on the ad to register. “OMG!!!!!!,” he wrote.
Others expressed outrage, with one writing, “Racism being deemed as ‘controversial,’ ‘edgy,’ and ‘dark,’ is insane,” referring to Busted Broadway’s disclaimer about their projects. “Who would even sit in a room & just write this?” one asked.
Busted Broadway, an independent record label composed of a team of artists, is based in New Jersey and promotes itself as a producer of satirical comedy albums. “Busted Broadway is not for the mollycoddled or politically correct listener,” the company warns on its About page.
Their past recording projects have explored unconventional topics, including abstinence, the historical figure Genghis Khan, and the disturbing premise of the human centipede.
One of the people behind Busted Broadway is Kevin Lynch, a polarizing figure in theater, who filed lawsuits against theater organizations for alleged race and sex discrimination, apprenticeship programs, and diversity initiatives such as BIPOC Night.
The debate over what is acceptable to joke about isn’t new. Earlier this year, comedian Tony Hinchcliffe faced severe criticism after making a joke about Floyd on Netflix’s “The Roast of Kevin Hart.”
While Hart defended the joke as part of the roast’s deliberately offensive format, Floyd’s family and many others condemned it as insensitive.
While satire often relies on discomfort and provocation, critics argue that there is a difference between mocking serious issues and making a joke out of a tragic situation. Ultimately, the controversy raises the question of whether artistic freedom should come with limits when the focus involves real people and the tragedy continues to resonate with the public.
Auto Amazon Links: No products found.