So, Taylor Swift’s latest transformation has everyone talking—because, hey, when Mars is strutting through Leo, you expect a little extra fire and flair, right? She’s dropped the muted, brooding “Tortured Poet” vibe for a splash of bright oranges and showgirl shimmer with her new album, “The Life of a Showgirl,” released October 3rd. But here’s the kicker: while some fans are loving the bolder, more exposed “Anti-Hero” swagger, a chunk of the crowd is oddly convinced that Taylor’s sex appeal just… misses the beat. Like, can someone born under a sign of cosmic reinvention not own the stage with oomph? A Reddit thread even popped up dissecting this peculiarity, comparing Tay to effortlessly sultry collaborators like Lana Del Rey and Sabrina Carpenter. What’s up with this disconnect—is it just the star seeing too many spotlights, or does genuine sexiness demand a secret sauce Taylor simply doesn’t pour? Let’s dive into how the Swiftie universe is blurring cosmic glam with earthbound critique—and maybe, just maybe, uncover if Taylor’s showgirl act is an astrological experiment gone sideways or a misunderstood masterpiece. LEARN MORE

Pop star Taylor Swift is best known for her music, but she’s also known for her differing personas. During her last album, she was the chair of the Tortured Poets Department and filled her palette with lots of muted colors. She has since embraced a lot of bright colors, especially orange, for her showgirl era, after “The Life of a Showgirl” dropped on October 3. Although some fans love to see the “Anti-Hero” singer showing more skin, others have criticized the pop star and claimed that she lacks “sex appeal.
Article continues below advertisement
Pre-order The Life of a Showgirl: “It’s Beautiful” Limited Release Deluxe CD now on my site. Available for 72 hours while supplies last. ❤️🔥 https://t.co/rIaG2EzVXx
Album Producers: Max Martin, Shellback and Taylor Swift
📸: Mert Alas & Marcus Piggott pic.twitter.com/9GZ5aJBF7D— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) August 14, 2025
One user took to Reddit to ask others if they also felt that the singer lacked sex appeal. They included a photo wearing a glittery navy blue sports bra and cheeky sports while performing on the Eras Tour.
They followed it up with a few more Eras Tour costumes, along with a sleeveless floral dress that the “Cruel Summer” singer wore during a late-night appearance promoting her new album.
Article continues below advertisement
Tonight all these lives converge here
The mosaics of laughter and cocktails of tears
Where fraternal souls sing identical things
And it’s beautiful
It’s rapturous.
It is frightening.
———
I can’t tell you how proud I am to share this with you, an album that just feels so right. A… pic.twitter.com/jIEG65ptR6— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) October 3, 2025
The user emphasized that they were not trying to be “rude,” but they felt that the pop star just didn’t make it “click.” They went on to say that she is “conventionally pretty” and definitely not “ugly,” but it just “doesn’t” work. They pointed to sensual songs like “Dress” and “Wildest Dreams” as proof that the singer does have a sexy side, but noted that “there’s a disconnect.”
However, they went on to say that artists like Lana Del Rey and Sabrina Carpenter, both of whom have collaborated with Taylor in the past, seem to pull off being effortlessly sexy. “What do you think causes this effect where she just doesn’t have it, but someone else like Sabrina Carpenter or Lana Del Rey do?” they asked. “It doesn’t have anything to do with actual looks imo. Thoughts?”
Article continues below advertisement
The Life of a Showgirl: Baby, That’s Show Business Vinyl Collection is available now on my site for 48 hours while supplies last ❤️🔥https://t.co/WdrCmvLHyA
Album Producers: Max Martin, Shellback and Taylor Swift
📸: Mert Alas & Marcus Piggott pic.twitter.com/ExVQpnEyOk— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) August 21, 2025
The top comment noted that Taylor doesn’t seem “comfortable in herself and her body” and called her “completely humorless.” They said that they found her “too rigid” and expressed that her mannerisms come off as “awkward.”
“Yeah, sex appeal is like a je ne sais quoi that can’t be quantified, but a lot of it starts with being at home in your body and knowing what gets you going,” another agreed. “She’s spent her whole life focusing on her men that I don’t think she even knows.”
Article continues below advertisement
Pre-order The Life of a Showgirl: “It’s Frightening” Limited Release Deluxe CD now on my site. Available for 72 hours while supplies last ❤️🔥 https://t.co/rIaG2EzVXx
Album Producers: Max Martin, Shellback and Taylor Swift
📸: Mert Alas & Marcus Piggott pic.twitter.com/OcYLCXl1zm— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) August 14, 2025
Another user offered an interesting take, explaining that she is always “on” and knows she’s being watched; therefore, she isn’t able to just let herself go. “She’s too acutely aware of what people see and how she’s perceived, so she’s never able to let go to exude anything remotely genuine,” they wrote.
Other fans felt that her lack of sex appeal, especially when dancing, was actually relatable! “I cannot dance sexy for the life of me. I’ve tried it in front of the mirror one time and cringed,” they wrote. “I agree, there’s nothing wrong with not feeling comfortable with doing that.”
To get more updates on Taylor Swift and her latest album, make sure to follow The Blast on Facebook!
Auto Amazon Links: No products found.

This will close in 0 seconds
This will close in 0 seconds