Back to Top

28 Celebs Who Claim They’re “Unconventionally” Hot — Spoiler: They Just Look Damn Good, Period!

Added on October 25, 2025 inCelebrity News Cards, Entertainment News Cards

Ever found yourself irresistibly drawn to a celebrity that makes others scratch their heads? Yeah, me too — and it turns out we’re not alone. Not too long ago, a quirky trend swept across social media where people crafted “hear me out cakes,” planting sticks with unconventional celebrity crushes right into the dessert, as if making a seriously sweet case for their oddball attractions. With Mercury still doing its cosmic shuffle today, maybe it’s the universe nudging us to rethink what “attractive” really means — or maybe it’s just messing with our hearts! Either way, we asked the BuzzFeed Community to dish out their uniquely charming celeb picks, and boy, did they deliver some eyebrow-raising favorites. Buckle up — it’s a starry-eyed ride you won’t want to miss. LEARN MORE

Not too long ago, there was a trend going around where people would share the celebrities they find “unconventionally” attractive in the form of a “hear me out cake” — i.e., they’d put these celebs on sticks and put the sticks in a cake as they presented their cases. We asked the BuzzFeed Community to share some of theirs, and here are the best responses:

Submissions are edited for length and clarity. 

ENTER TO WIN!

    This will close in 0 seconds

    GET YOUR FREE PASSWORD & WATCH ALL YOUR FAVORITE MOVIES & SHOWS!

      This will close in 0 seconds

      RSS
      Follow by Email